Share It

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Biggest Loser: No room for gameplay

Biggest Loser logo

I watched The Biggest Loser on DVR at 2am last night and was just too tired to post any reflections about it. However, I was thinking about it on my way to work this morning.

This season is different. Yes, it's the same trainers. Same host. Same shameless product placements. Even the same outrageously large weights at the start of the season. But this season's contestants are different. This season's contestants are supportive of each other. They truly want to see others succeed. They definitely seem to be there for their health, not their wallets.

The only real game player has been Melissa. Once she left the ranch several weeks ago, there seemed to be a lightening of spirits. When she returned last week, no one was throwing her a "welcome back" party. Melissa never made any secret of the fact that she was all about the game -- and I have to give her credit for that. At least she wasn't skulking around being all sneaky about it.

But her desire to play the game did not make her a favorite in the house. In fact, last night's swim challenge in which each player had to move 100 1-pounds weights from the bottom of the pool to a bin on the edge of the pool, demonstrated that quite clearly. Sunshine won the challenge and then moved on to help her father, O'Neal, finish. Sam, who came in second, also helped O'Neal. As each person finished, he or she worked to help another player. The player who came in last would receive a 1 pound disadvantage at the scale. The only person who did not receive help was Melissa.

She viewed that as stupidity, that people weren't trying to knock out the biggest threats in the house, that they obviously didn't understand how to play the game. What Melissa didn't understand is that the players this season don't care about gameplay. At least not yet.

When Melissa fell below the bottom line with Drea, her plea to those who would be deciding her fate was "I'm your fairy godmother. I can't beat you. So keep me and pick off everyone else one at a time." In other seasons, her argument would have been persuasive. But not this season. And so, with five consecutive votes, Melissa was sent packing once again.

I thought that her tearful display of emotion at being forced to leave the ranch for a second time was one of the few times we've seen her real self, instead of this tough competitor image she's projected throughout this season.

To Drea's credit, while she could have been smug and think "I've got this; no one likes Melissa," she didn't. She offered her own plea for why she should stay on the ranch.

I don't think the remainder of the season will be devoid of gameplay. As the numbers dwindle, people will be forced to make alliances and to make difficult decisions which will certainly be influenced by what's best for themselves. The next most likely gameplayer, in my opinion, is Koli. We saw him place seeds of doubt about Stephanie in Ashley's mind. And I think he's getting frustrated by his cousin Sam's success while his own weight loss has not been as remarkable.

So I'm sure the games will take place. But last night anyway, it was refreshing to see that there was no room for gameplay.

6 comments:

Jessica said...

I'm SOOO glad that Melissa is gone AGAIN. I like this season a lot better because it hasn't been all about the game play for the majority of the contestants.

Joanie M said...

I was a happy happy lady last night when they sent Melissa packing!! And the best part is, her weight loss was low without the 1 pounds disadvantage!!!

Yeah, this season IS different, at least for now.

Did you see Michael trot up the steps? Go Michael!!!

I'm REALLY liking Sunshine!!

I say keep an eye on Victoria. I think she's playing dumb like a fox.

Yeah, the green-eyed monster may show up in Koli soon, although his numbers are impressive too.

Watch next week for Drea, Daris and Koli to show big numbers since they were so low this week.

Remember last week, Sam was below the yellow line? This week he lost 10 pounds!

Daris and Koli... throwing their weight this week to get big numbers next week? Maybe Sam did it last week? I don't think Drea did... she seemed genuinely upset by the 2 pound loss. We shall see.

Marine Wife said...

I missed it AND forgot to DVR it last night. So glad to have you to recap it for me!

Janet said...

Do you think that these folks realize that gameplay = stress = limited weight loss?

One thing I find interesting is that they never mention (at least what I have heard) the role harmones play with a women's weight loss/gain. Maybe it is just an old wives tale -- but there is a week each month where I have more water weight regardless of what I do.

Joanne said...

Why did I not know that Melissa was a lawyer - I threw up a bit in my mouth over her "plea" to the jury - I mean housemates.

Glad to see her GONE - AGAIN!!!!

Although I loved Michael's comment that "we haven't played game this season" - ok who was the person that split the house blue and black all stacked??? Oh ya it was Mike!! Gotta love selective memory.

Joanie M said...

Good point, Joanne!